Rice Lake National Wildlife Refuge, pictured August 14, 2025, features acres of productive wild rice beds. Credit: Aaron Nesheim | Sahan Journal

A bipartisan bill that would dramatically remake permitting regulations in the United States passed the Senate in a 62-33 vote late Thursday despite nationwide tribal opposition. 

The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) has proved highly divisive, sparking intense debate as it has moved through the Senate. Environmental and tribal groups have warned it would cut out tribal voices and accelerate environmentally damaging projects, while supporters argue it could remove red tape for developing new projects and accelerate clean energy development. 

The bill includes shortened permitting timelines and reduces legal avenues to block projects in court, while also making federal leases automatically renewable.

At least five of Minnesota’s 11 federally recognized tribes have publicly opposed the bill, while  nationwide more than 70 have expressed opposition to provisions that reduce the amount of tribal consultation required. Environmental groups in Minnesota have likewise criticized the bill for potentially enabling the development of the Twin Metals mine outside the Boundary Waters wilderness. 

As the bill moves to the House with a vote likely during the current lame-duck session, the perspective from Minnesota tribes is clear. 

“This bill attacks our sovereignty, it attacks tribal consultation, and it attacks us having the ability to protect our sites,” said Grant Johnson, president of the Prairie Island Indian Community. 

Tribal opposition

Tribal nations across the country are particularly concerned about the bill’s effect on Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA), which regulates consultation on projects sited on tribal land. 

“Some of the proposed changes to Section 106 could drastically curtail meaningful tribal consultation, including when consultation takes place,” said Franky Jackson, a compliance officer at Prairie Island Indian Community.

Tribes would have 45 days to respond to Section 106 reports for projects, a timeline many tribal groups say is insufficient. The bill would also expand federal agencies’ authority to make decisions on the effects of a project on historically and culturally significant sites.

In a statement to Sahan Journal, Robert Deschampe, chairman of the Grand Portage Band of Lake Superior Chippewa, said those changes diminish meaningful consultation.

“That’s checking off a box,” Deschampe said. “We are supposed to be involved before decisions are made that impact us, not after.”

Several amendments were introduced to soften the impact on tribes, but Johnson said it still significantly reduces tribes’ ability to offer meaningful consultation.

“The current amendments in the bill have not addressed the concerns that the tribes have,” Johnson said.

The Fond du Lac Band of the Chippewa, Leech Lake Band of the Ojibwe, and Lower Sioux Indian Community have also publicly opposed the bill. Chief executive of the Mille Lacs Band of the Ojibwe Virgil Wind also expressed opposition to the bill in a statement to Sahan Journal, saying it undermined tribal sovereignty. 

In a November 8 letter to Minnesota Senators Tina Smith and Amy Klobuchar, Deschampe said that the Senate amendments alone were not enough. 

Senator Amy Klobuchar celebrates her re-election at the Minnesota DFL watch party on November 5, 2024. Credit: Aaron Nesheim | Sahan Journal

“Applauding these changes [to the bill], however, would be akin to applauding a polluter for

destroying most of our manoomin [wild rice] rather than all of it,” the letter read. 

Smith has opposed the bill since its introduction, repeatedly voting against advancing the bill and ultimately against its passage. Klobuchar, Minnesota’s governor-elect, voted in favor of it.  In a statement to Sahan Journal, Johnson expressed disappointment with the result of the final vote.

“We are very disappointed that Senators chose to pass BAAJA in a form that is so against the Tribes of this nation,” the statement read. “We implore the House of Representatives to hear the pleas and wisdom of Tribal leaders and others and make adjustments to the bill that avoid irreparable damage.”

In a statement to Sahan Journal, Klobuchar cited the need to modernize the permitting process as factoring in her decision. 

“I have long supported modernizing our permitting process to lower costs, get more affordable clean energy onto the grid, and create good-paying jobs,” the statement read. “But I have also been clear that this legislation needed improvements to strengthen Tribal and environmental protections. 

“I voted for the bill because I believe it will help address longstanding permitting challenges, but there is more to do to ensure stronger protections are included in law in the future.”

With its passage in the Senate, the bill now moves to the House, where opinions on it also are split. Johnson said that Minnesota tribes have reached out to House members to express their disapproval of the bill. 

Johnson added that he recognizes the importance of  making the process more efficient, but emphasized that the bill in its current form does so at the expense of tribal nations. 

“I think everybody wants to work on the reform of the permitting process and moving projects forward,” he said. “[But the] attack of our sovereignty and attack of the ability for us to have consultation and the ability to protect our sites, I think that’s the piece that we’re starting to see and gain more support.”

Boundary Waters at risk

Tribes and environmental groups have also expressed concern that the BAAJA will green light mining development on the edge of the Boundary Waters wilderness.

In April, a House Joint Resolution overturned a 20-year federal ban on mineral and geothermal leasing near the Boundary Waters. The resolution opened the door for the approval of the Twin Metals Minnesota project, owned by Chilean mining conglomerate Antofagasta, within the Boundary Waters watershed. The mine would harvest sulfite-ore minerals including copper, cobalt and nickel. 

In his letter to Smith and Klobuchar, Deschampe stressed the risks the mine posed to the Boundary Waters, saying the passage of the BAAJA would weaken tribes’ ability to review proposed leases there. He also emphasized the cultural and ecological significance the wilderness holds to the Chippewa.

“Manoomin [wild rice] is sacred to the Band and has sustained our people for generations,” the letter read. “It cannot survive in polluted waters. By eliminating the Band’s existing authorities under Section 106, this bill would open the door to that pollution.”

Environmental groups in Minnesota have likewise been vocal in opposing the bill. Ingrid Lyons, executive director at Save the Boundary Waters, said that the mines could create irreversible damage to the Boundary Waters’ aquatic ecosystems.

“Copper mining and hard rock mining is one of the most toxic and polluting industries according to the Environmental Protection Agency,” Lyons said. “It’s a unique ecosystem that is also uniquely vulnerable to the type of pollution that comes from sulfur or copper mining.”

Environmental groups say a provision of the bill that would prevent federal agencies from revoking, suspending, or modifying approved permits is particularly harmful. 

“It could just lock in mining projects indefinitely,” said Pete Marshall, communications director at Friends of the Boundary Waters. “This would basically make it so that future administrations, even if it’s issued illegally or improperly, couldn’t do anything.”

Environmental advocates and tribal groups have also expressed concern about the bill’s effect on legal pathways to block projects in court. Parties would need to have previously filed a comment on the specific issue they are litigating, allege direct harm as a result of the project, and would only have 150 days to file. 

“To eliminate that [ability to sue] means that projects can potentially go forward that will do irreparable damage and that can’t be undone,” said Jessie Stomski, legal counsel at Prairie Island Indian Community.

In Minnesota, advocates are pushing for stronger state legislation to shield the Boundary Waters from mining development. Governor Tim Walz’s August executive order banned state environmental review, permitting and new mineral leasing for nonferrous mining near the Boundary Waters, but expires 90 days after he turns the governor’s chair over to Klobuchar in January. Marshall and Lyons both said they hope the next state legislative session could secure permanent protections for the Boundary Waters. 

Lyons added that the timing of the BAAJA could complicate the ability of the state legislature to block the Twin Metals mine. 

For Deschampe, blocking the BAAJA is the most pressing issue.

“State protections alone can’t replace the federal government’s responsibility to uphold treaty rights and protect these waters,” he said. “BAAJA would weaken important federal safeguards at the exact moment in history when we are faced with multiple new extraction proposals.”

“Tribal consultation is working”

To the leadership team at Prairie Island Indian Community, the BAAJA’s tribal consultation provisions are based on a misconception about tribes’ attitude toward most projects. 

“I think what some folks are trying to highlight is that tribes are holding up the [permitting] process,” Johnson said. “That’s far from the truth.”

According to the National Trust for Historic Preservation, of the approximately 120,000 annual federal undertakings reviewed each year under Section 106 of the NHPA, 98% are found to have no adverse effect, and less than .01% result in litigation in federal court.

Johnson said Prairie Island’s experience with the development of a nuclear power facility, the closest nuclear plant to a community anywhere in the country, informs the tribe’s opposition to the BAAJA. He said that the consultation processes established under the NHPA benefit all parties.

“This process that’s in place now is very impactful to recognize the harms that were done in the past,” he said. “We’re able to correct that moving forward in the future.”

Jackson agreed, highlighting Prairie Island’s memorandum of understanding  with the city of Red Wing that helps clarify how state agencies and the tribe consult. As part of that process, Jackson said several artifacts were ultimately repatriated to the tribe, including the Jefferson Peace and Friendship Medal that was unearthed in a Red Wing road project in the late 1800s. 

“There are some brilliant examples of how tribal consultation is working locally here in Minnesota,” he said. “I think some of those stories need to be highlighted.”

Nicolas Scibelli is a freelance journalist and intern for Sahan Journal and a graduate student at the University of Minnesota studying reforestation. His work has appeared in Yale Climate Connections and...