When Abby Lee told her coworkers she had been cast on a reality TV show, some assumed she meant “The Bachelor.” Instead, she was heading to the Scottish Highlands to compete on NBC’s murder mystery competition, “The Traitors.”

Lee, 29, is a third-generation Korean American who grew up in St. Paul, where she attended Central High School. Her grandparents immigrated to Minnesota in the 1960s. She now lives in California.

“I liked growing up in Minnesota but there weren’t a lot of other Koreans,” Lee said. “It was really hard to not grow up around any other Asian people. I think just for my kids, I’d want them to grow up somewhere that’s more diverse.”

Lee now lives in the San Francisco Bay Area, where she is a NASA Hubble Fellow and Miller Postdoctoral Research Fellow at the University of California, Berkeley. She had been watching “The Traitors” for years before a twist in the program gave her an opportunity to apply.

The U.S. series had previously featured celebrities and reality television personalities. For its fifth season, “New Blood,” producers selected from more than 80,000 applicants for its all-new civilian version. The contestants came from across the country and a range of professions, including a funeral director, a therapist and a pilot. 

“I couldn’t believe they chose me,” Lee said. “It felt like a dream come true because when else do we get to just play games like that as an adult with other adults? I thought that time of my life was over.”

Hosted by Scottish actor Alan Cumming, the season offers a prize of up to $250,000, which contestants can earn by completing challenges throughout the competition – and staying “alive.” 

Among the 22 players, three were secretly appointed “traitors.” The remaining contestants, known as “faithfuls,” must identify and banish the traitors before they are eliminated, or “murdered,” one by one. Seated at a roundtable at the end of each episode, the players vote to banish one player they suspect of being a traitor. If they successfully banish every traitor, they split the prize money. If a traitor survives until the end, the traitors win.

By the time Lee boarded the train in May to Ardross Castle, where the show is shot, part of the cast had already spent about an hour bonding. 

She and the other late contestants jokingly called themselves the “bombshells,” a term from the dating show “Love Island,” when latecomers are sent in to shake up existing couples. 

“When I got into the train, there were already eight people and they were all friends,” Lee said. “I was like, ‘Okay, already behind.’”

Before setting foot inside Ardross Castle, Lee had a plan for nearly everything. She watched every season of the American and British series. She took notes on the strategies that helped contestants win and the missteps that sent players home. She even mapped out what she would do on each day of the competition.

“I prepared for it like I would prepare for any research project,” Lee said. 

Lee studies the expansion of the universe and the formation of galaxies. Her interest in astrophysics began in high school, after watching Christopher Nolan’s film “Interstellar.” She expected the analytical skills she developed as a researcher — evaluating competing theories and defending her conclusions — to help her identify the Traitors at the roundtable.

The reality of the game, however, was far less predictable. 

“I had a full 100-page notebook of plans and strategies and all of them were completely useless,” she said. 

On the first day of the competition, the contestants sat blindfolded around the roundtable as Cumming secretly selected the first two traitors: Joe Vanella, a funeral director from Long Island, N.Y., and Tomica Adams, a pilot from Boston. Katie Fites, a marketing manager from Jacksonville, Fla., was later selected as the third traitor. 

Lee was designated one of the “faithfuls,” and decided that the best way to survive was not to attract attention. She planned to say little, appear harmless and keep her profession to herself. If she could help it, she wouldn’t give the other contestants a reason to question her. She survived multiple rounds, but fell under suspicion and was mistakenly banished by the group in the eighth episode.

“I was so nervous,” Lee said. “I think I might have been the most paranoid person in that castle just because I’m such a competitive person. I really didn’t care about any of the things that came afterwards like influencer deals, or whatever. I really just wanted to win.”

Lee kept lists of contestants she considered definite traitors, possible traitors and definite faithfuls, revising her suspicions as the game progressed. 

“I actually had a lot of trouble sleeping. I would probably sleep on average two hours a night,” she said. “We get home at 2 a.m. and you don’t have any time the whole day to think and just be by yourself. 2 a.m. was the only time I had, so I would just lie in bed and everything was running through my head.” 

That uncertainty followed her into the mornings, too. Each day, she had to wait until breakfast to find out whether she had survived the night or been ‘murdered’ by the traitors. 

Lee said the contestants “trauma bonded” quickly. She grew especially close to Morgan Cook, a social media content creator from Chicago,  who was “murdered” by unknowingly drinking from a poisoned chalice on the episode after Lee was banished. She also bonded with Kriste Lewis, a realtor from Hattiesburg Miss., who remains in the competition as a faithful, and Vanella, who was exposed as a traitor. 

“Even if you think someone’s a traitor, if they’re your best friend, you should never vote for them,” she said. 

“Joe was really supportive to me the whole time and looking back, I think that was hard for him,” Lee added. “I would tell him every day, ‘Joe, I’m so scared of getting murdered. I’m having a panic attack,’ and he’s like, ‘It’s okay. Don’t worry about it.’ Looking back, that’s kind of funny.” 

Lee preferred playing a faithful. 

“To be a good traitor, you basically just have to be charismatic and a good liar,” she said. “To be a good faithful, that’s so much more complicated, and there’s so much more gameplay involved.”

“Astrophysicists are extremely passionate about their theories,” she said. “I didn’t want to sit at the round table and say nothing when I had my own theories.”

If Lee could play again, she said she would rely more on her instincts. 

“I had a gut feeling that Katie was a traitor the entire time I was there but there was no evidence that she was,” Lee said. “She was so confident and she never seemed nervous.”

After Vanella and Adams were exposed as traitors, Fites became the only remaining traitor. In the final few episodes, she recruited one more traitor, leaving two traitors and six faithful heading into the finale. 

“Looking back, the best strategy is stay quiet, make as many friends as you can and go off your gut feeling, which is totally the opposite of what I expected,” Lee said. 

Lee had spent months preparing for the competition, but she hadn’t given much thought to what would happen once the episodes reached viewers. Having largely stayed off social media, she created an Instagram account when she was announced as a contestant and was caught off guard by the negative comments directed at her and the other contestants.

“It was really weird to see hundreds of people go, ‘Oh, this person’s so stupid,’ and it wasn’t just me. It was everyone getting comments and because we’re all regular people, it was really disconcerting,” Lee said. “It opened my eyes a lot to the nature of the internet.” 

Her husband now manages her Instagram account. Still, Lee said she would return to the competition, this time as a traitor if she could. 

“Playing the game was the greatest adventure of my entire life,” she said. “I had a goal. I wanted to make it to episode four and I made it way farther.” 

“The Traitors” premiered on NBC on Sept. 17, with episodes also streaming on Peacock. The season finale airs Thursday, Nov. 19.

Myah Goff is a freelance journalist and photographer, exploring the intersection of art and culture. With a journalism degree from the University of Minnesota and a previous internship at Sahan Journal,...