In early May, the United States Supreme Court ruled in favor of the Trump administration’s order to terminate Temporary Protected Status (TPS) for Venezuelans.
The administration also chose to revoke TPS for Afghans in the United States.
Temporary Protected Status is an immigration classification that protects people from deportation and allows them to work in the United States. People from these countries have often experienced threats from armed conflict, environmental disasters or other forms of acute danger. In revoking TPS, the Trump administration declared that Afghanistan and Venezuela are safe places to return — a conclusion at odds with most accounts from people inside the countries.
The administration’s revocation means that some 3,000 Venezuelans and 3,000 Afghans living in Minnesota can be deported. Many immigrants from these countries say they fear political persecution if they were to return home.
On Thursday, May 29, Sahan Journal invited two experts to share the experiences of community members and clients who are trying to navigate the changing landscape of immigration in the United States.
- Nasreen Sajady is the executive director of the Afghan Cultural Society, in Minneapolis
- Ana Pottratz Acosta is a professor at Mitchell Hamline School of Law, in St. Paul
In an hourlong Instagram Live conversation, Sajady and Pottratz Acosta discussed the confusing barrage of federal orders and legal decisions that affect TPS holders in Minnesota. They also took questions from viewers. Here are 10 takeaways from the conversation.
What is TPS?
Temporary Protected Status, or TPS, is a short-term immigration status granted to people from nations experiencing natural disasters or civil turmoil. It allows people to live and work in the United States, on a nation-by-nation basis, and was authorized by Congress in 1990.
Why have Afghans and Venezuelans received TPS status?
Following the fall of the Afghan government and the resurgence of the Taliban in 2021, the Biden administration granted TPS to Afghanistan. Similarly, the Biden administration granted TPS to Venezuelans after worsening political persecution and humanitarian crises under the rule of President Nicolás Maduro.
Why are Afghans in Minnesota afraid to return home?
According to Nasreen Sajady, Afghans tell her they fear retribution from the Taliban because of their previous political involvement or their history of assisting the U.S. military.
Why don’t Venezuelans in Minnesota feel it’s safe to return home?
According to Ana Pottratz Acosta, Venezuelan nationals fear arrests and political persecution in Venezuela.
Who in the U.S. government determined Afghanistan and Venezuela are safe for returning migrants?
In order to terminate TPS, the Secretary of Homeland Security must assess whether conditions are safe for return. Secretary Kristi Noem announced in February and early May that conditions were safe in Venezuela and Afghanistan — an opinion at odds with widespread reporting about political persecution in both countries.
What happens to immigrants from Afghanistan and Venezuela who’ve lost TPS status?
Despite the end of TPS for Venezuelans and Afghans, both groups may have strong asylum claims based on political dangers faced in their home countries, according to Pottratz Acosta.
What should Afghan and Venezuelan immigrants do to manage their new situation?
As the Trump administration tries to expedite the deportation process, Pottratz Acosta recommends people who’ve had TPS carry proof of their legal status at all times. This action may reduce the likelihood that they will be wrongfully detained and give them a stronger legal claim if they are wrongfully detained.
How can immigrants manage the stress of these challenges?
Afghans in Minnesota under TPS have expressed mounting fear of returning to Afghanistan, Sajady said. But she’s been advising clients to remain focused on trying to build a new life in the United States. She notes that her nonprofit, the Afghan Cultural Society focuses on offering community and solace to those under distress. Amid growing fears, the Afghan Cultural Society continues to hold events featuring food and music, providing a sense of community to Afghans in Minnesota.
Is it safe for TPS and asylum seekers to travel?
Pottratz Acosta recommends that these immigrant groups avoid international travel due to the risks associated with re-entry to the United States. With or without a passport, it is possible to be detained by customs. However, she added, there shouldn’t be a problem with traveling domestically.
What’s the situation for children born in the United States?
Children born in the U.S. are U.S. citizens under the Fourteenth Amendment of the Constitution. However, the Supreme Court is actively hearing arguments for an executive order that seeks to terminate that clause. Pottratz Acosta suggests families apply for a U.S. passport for their U.S.-born children. This process may strengthen immigration claims for families seeking TPS or asylum.
Disclosure: For this story, Sahan newsroom staff used artificial intelligence to help us quickly transcribe audio from the video livestream and compile an outline of key takeaways. A Sahan reporter and editor took these starting materials to draft the list, above. Using AI allowed us to efficiently adapt our live video interview into a story for Sahan’s website.
You can watch a recording of the livestream and read the full, lightly edited transcript below.
